Hindsight is always 20-20 but if you had the first pick, who would your choice have been? There seemed to be some genuine surprise that I didn't take Halladay or Webb. For the record, as much as I loved Halladay I'm not so sure the offense would have allowed him to duplicate several career numbers. Webb would have been my first pitching choice and I still love Halladay as a pick but I just couldn't let Longoria pass. I chose to bet on the next tier of pitchers rising up. What would you have done?

Kelly you made the right choice and I figured you would go with Longoria. I already had A. Rameriez at third so my choice was Webb, but would have been happy with Halliday. Last year I punted pitching and I got punted in a soft spot so hopefully I learned from my errors.

Kelly, if I had the first pick I would have gone with Halladay. I just think that he is one of the top 3 pitchers in the game and I wouldn't be able to pass on him.
With that said, I still think you have a great looking team!

Kelly,I think I would have taken Halladay because he is one of the top pitchers,gives you 34 starts,most quality but most of all you had to wait 23 rounds before you can draft a P.You had 3 excellent keepers & as good as Longoria is you have left yourself short as far as pitching goes.Only time will tell.You do have an infield we would all love to have tho.

First pick in a keeper league has to be someone you think will be a keeper. Longoria sure fits that. If you think he is near the player the hype says, he has to be the guy. I heard Halilaay & Webb might go 1/2. I was still deciding if I would take Longoria or Mauer in the 3 slot.