My 2 cents.. Ok with in-season trading but would vote for first third of season, maybe end of May. Unless. All Star break is much more than half of the season and maybe too far for our league. What might work for All Star break deadline though is if we said all trades okay except keepers.. Could allow for that guy that stumbled on 3 good second baseman to get a decent pitcher for example. We all might be more amendable to any rule out of fear of balance/collusion if we exclude keepers.