Poland and Polish Discussion Group and Forum

Welcome to the original English language Poland and Polish discussion group board. This message forum is a place where English-speaking Poles, foreigners (expats) living in Poland, and anyone with a genuine interest in Poland can discuss and read the views of others concerning Poland. Subjects include: Polish news and current affairs; Life in Poland; politics; genealogy research; Polish culture and history; advice and tips on visiting Poland; Polish property and investment issues. The aim of our group is to increase awareness of wonderful Poland using the English language and allow and foster the honest debate and exchange of opinions on anything vaguely related to Poland and Polish - positive, negative and/or neutral! To state the obvious: all opinions and views expressed on this site are solely those of their respective authors and are not necessarily those of anyone else! Messages consisting of ads will be deleted.

Links:  Poland Directory; Polish Language Forum; Factbook Poland; Photographs of Poland; Polish TranslationA Town in Poland; Map

Poland and Polish Discussion Group and Forum
Start a New Topic 
Poland's unsteady government

From the Economist ...

Poland's unsteady government

Crash, bang, fizzle

The ruling coalition wobbles, but survives for now

OUTSIDERS often mock Poland's prickly, obstinate prime minister, Jaroslaw Kaczynski. But a collapse of his government, followed by months of instability, might be worse. An anti-corruption watchdog this week named a deputy prime minister, the temperamental farmers' leader Andrzej Lepper, in a bribery scandal. Mr Kaczynski promptly sacked him (for the second time).

Mr Lepper, who denies any wrongdoing, threatened to take his party, Self-Defence, out of the coalition. That would have meant minority rule and perhaps an early election, bogging down Poland's haphazard reforms completely. The European Union's most unpredictable member would be even harder to handle. But Self-Defence does not want an election campaign in which its already pungent reputation for cronyism might take centre stage. Fearing a revolt, Mr Lepper apparently backed down, suggesting his party may stay in the coalition “conditionally”.

Mr Kaczynski's Law and Justice Party may also want to defuse a row with its hardline Catholic supporters before facing voters. Father Tadeusz Rydzyk, who runs a highly politicised media empire, recently called Mr Kaczynski's sister-in-law a “witch” who deserved “euthanasia” because of her support for abortion. That prompted a rebuke from her husband, Lech Kaczynski, Jaroslaw's twin brother and Poland's president.

Law and Justice's embrace has proved near-fatal to the other coalition party, the nationalist League of Polish Families. It may now do the same for Self-Defence. Mr Kaczynski can thus safely go for an early election whenever he chooses. But his canny politicking is not matched by ability to govern. Attempts at health reform, for example, have brought doctors at more than 200 hospitals out on strike. Nurses demanding higher wages are camping in tents outside Mr Kaczynski's office. They say he has broken election pledges to help losers from the post-1989 transition, such as ill-paid public-sector workers.

The government has also failed to reform public finances, essential if Poland is to follow Cyprus and Malta into the euro (see article). Its main boasts are reforms in the intelligence services, stronger anti-corruption efforts and weeding out communist-era secret-police collaborators. These may have been worthwhile, but the government's approach has been highly partisan, even vengeful. Public administration is lamentably backward.

As the political system fails to reflect Poles' exasperation with their poor quality of life, many are voting with their feet. Some 2m have gone abroad since Poland joined the EU, and a recent survey found another 3m planning to do the same. This is aggravating labour shortages that may undermine the country's competitiveness.

Poland's foreign policy is also being mismanaged. At the recent EU summit, Mr Kaczynski won a delay on new voting rules that will reduce Poland's weight. But the victory was marred by his graceless approach, using Poland's wartime suffering at German hands as a bargaining chip. It was Germany that pushed hardest for Poland's EU entry. Now German diplomats in Warsaw say relations cannot improve so long as the Kaczynskis are in power.

On the foreign front, things may get worse still. Law and Justice has just suspended its most sensible foreign-affairs expert, Pawel Zalewski. A deputy leader of the party, he dared to quiz the lightweight foreign minister, Anna Fotyga, at a parliamentary hearing. The disconnection between Poland and its EU partners was underlined when a Polish candidate to run the IMF was brushed aside. Both Poland and the EU would like to see a strong, dependable government in Warsaw. It may be some time before they get one.

Re: Poland's unsteady government

Right wing nationalists, Samoobrona and LPR (League of Polish families), look likely to join forces as a new party "LiS" (League and Defence). Elections would then follow.

Re: Poland's unsteady government

"Right wing nationalists, Samoobrona and LPR (League of Polish families), look likely to join forces as a new party "LiS" (League and Defence)"

"Self-defence", to be more accurate.
Now, that's an alliance of the century

Over onet.pl they have a hilarious list of readers' answers to the question: "What does acronym LiS mean?"
As most of you read/speak Polish, please let me quote my favourites in the original version:

"Lemiesz i Swastyka"
"Lipa i Syf"
"Lepper i Spółka"
"Lewo i Sprawiedliwość"

But seriously - if Samoobrona and LPR form and sustain a real coalition, early election will not be a problem for them. Together they will always get some 5 to 10% of votes (although idiocy is even more popular in every society) and it means that leaders (Lepper, Giertych and co.)shall become MP's again, which is about the only thing they care for.

Re: Poland's unsteady government

Lasica i Skurwysyny,
Lumpy i Szamby,
Likwidacja i Samoobojstwo

Re: Poland's unsteady government

Leniuchy i Sknerzy!

Re: Poland's unsteady government

Polish PM says decision to hold early polls in mid-November 'likely'

Warsaw - Poland's conservative Law and Justice (PiS) party Prime Minister Jaroslaw Kaczynski on Tuesday confirmed that early general elections in mid-November was a possibility for the European Union member country. The premier said an eventual decision to call an early election would be dictated by the behaviour of his two junior coalition parties, which on Monday decided to join forces to create a new political party

Leader of the populist Samoobrona farmers' party Andrzej Lepper and Roman Giertych, head of the Catholic-nationalist League of Polish Families (LPR) announced Monday they were creating a new party, Liga and Samoobrona (LiS)

According to analysts, the LiS, an acronym for "fox" in Polish, is designed to boost the chances of both marginally popular parties to surpass the 5 per cent voter threshold required to enter parliament.

The future of Kaczynski's coalition government was thrown into uncertainty Monday last week after he sacked Lepper from the post of agriculture minister over corruption allegations which, a week later, appear to be groundless.

Lepper has called for a special parliamentary committee to be set up to investigate the Anti-Corruption Bureau (CBA) operation into the re-zoning of agricultural land for commercial development. He claims the CBA tried to frame him.

CBA investigators and Polish justice ministry officials have declined to make public any concrete allegations against Lepper, who insists he is innocent.

Despite being sacked as deputy prime minister, Lepper decided Monday his Samoobrona party would not quit the governing coalition, thus averting an early election, at least for the time-being.

But regular threats by Kaczynski of an early general election have hung heavy over the Polish political scene since he took office in July 2006.

Anaylsts do not rule out a clearer win for Kaczynski, whose well-oiled party machine came from behind to win 2005 elections.