Poland and Polish Discussion Group and Forum

Welcome to the original English language Poland and Polish discussion group board. This message forum is a place where English-speaking Poles, foreigners (expats) living in Poland, and anyone with a genuine interest in Poland can discuss and read the views of others concerning Poland. Subjects include: Polish news and current affairs; Life in Poland; politics; genealogy research; Polish culture and history; advice and tips on visiting Poland; Polish property and investment issues. The aim of our group is to increase awareness of wonderful Poland using the English language and allow and foster the honest debate and exchange of opinions on anything vaguely related to Poland and Polish - positive, negative and/or neutral! To state the obvious: all opinions and views expressed on this site are solely those of their respective authors and are not necessarily those of anyone else! Messages consisting of ads will be deleted.

Links:  Poland Directory; Polish Language Forum; Factbook Poland; Photographs of Poland; Polish TranslationA Town in Poland; Map

Poland and Polish Discussion Group and Forum
Start a New Topic 
The Death Penalty and Abortion - the same?

"The council of Europe proclaimed this coming October 10th 'European day against the death sentence', despite the veto waved by Poland, which, as could be expected, is opposed to the creation of his day?, comments the Portuguese university scholar Carla Machado. Warsaw had proposed to create a 'defence of life day' instead, which would at once condemn the death penalty, abortion and euthanasia. "Curious, but not particularly innovative, the Polish attempt to compare the death penalty to abortion. ... The Polish attitude should make those concerned about radical Islamism or Turkish EU accession stop and think. Poland is already here ... and it does not seem to be showing any signs of the famous tolerance or open attitude to civilisation which is said to characterise European culture."


Re: The Death Penalty and Abortion - the same?


Warsaw's head-on clash with the European Union by vetoing a symbolic day against the death penalty is being interpreted here as a pre-electoral attempt to win domestic support for the so-called "Fourth Polish Republic" - a vision of a nation with a far wider sense of morality and democracy than existed under any past government.

The latest EU-Polish confrontation has come in the midst of a political crisis in Poland, after Prime Minister Jaroslaw Kaczynski from the ruling Law and Justice Party, PiS, dissolved the governing coalition and called early elections for Oct. 21.

On Sep. 18, Poland blocked a proposal by the Portuguese EU council presidency to mark a "European Day against the Death Penalty" on Oct. 10. This would have been a contribution to the World Day against the Death Penalty held annually by the Paris-based World Coalition against the Death Penalty.

Warsaw objected on the grounds that the EU proposal did not take into account the broader principle of the "right to life".

"If someone wants to discuss the death penalty, then he should also discuss banning euthanasia and abortion in the same context," Polish foreign ministry spokesman Robert Szaniawski told the press.

Polish Prime Minister Jaroslaw Kaczynski's alternative proposal was a "Day in Defence of Life".

The Council of Europe, where voting does not require unanimity, reacted swiftly to the Polish veto and the following week itself adopted Oct. 10 as the "European Day against Death Penalty". It also expressed the hope that all members of the EU would join in "as soon as possible".

On the same day, the European parliament also displayed solidarity by reiterating its support for the European anti-death penalty day initiative and expressing hope the next Polish government would support it.

Italian foreign minister Massimo D'Alema, currently working hard to win worldwide support for an EU-supported death penalty moratorium proposal, shortly to be presented to the UN General Assembly, expressed anger at the Polish veto. It was "reactionary and nationalistic", he said, adding that he hoped the current Polish government would suffer defeat in the upcoming elections.

But such public condemnation might only increase the Polish right's Euro-scepticism and win over other critics who see the EU stand on the death penalty as an overstepping of its mandate, Bobinski said.

It gave the ruling PiS party the opportunity to portray the pro-EU camp in Poland as those who "defend murderers -- unlike us", he said.

The death penalty and law-and-order issues have been controversial ones in Poland for months before the EU veto.

Last May, following a murder case involving the killing of a minor by a 19-year-old, who was later released, President Lech Kaczynski, the Prime Minister's twin brother, declared that it was "inadmissible when judges' views prevail over the moral beliefs of the general public".

Supreme Court President Lech Gardowcki replied by accusing the Kaczynski twins of undermining the justice system with their constant criticism and interference. They were pushing for tougher sentencing although crime rates were falling, he said.

Roman Giertych, the leader of the ultra-Catholic League of Polish Families, until recently a coalition partner in the government, has termed Europe's laws on crime as "anachronistic" and called for a referendum in favour of the restoration of capital punishment for the most extreme cases of murder and "paedophile murderers".

Giertych, who was education minister, had proposed schools should count religious lesson results in the final average class marks, mandatory school uniforms and separate schools for "aggressive youth", measures all welcomed by the Kaczynski brothers.

Giertych also had plans to abolish the teaching of Darwin's evolutionary theory in schools and to introduce anti-abortion classes to educate pupils about "the killing of unborn babies".

According to a March poll, 63 percent of Poles supported the death penalty, compared to 31 percent who opposed it. This reflected a widespread view that murderers often get away with overly light penalties, commentators said.

The Kaczynski brothers, to whom very few topics are taboo, have supported the death penalty as an effective tool in fighting corruption and crime. They campaigned for its restoration in the presidential and parliamentary elections of 2005.

Many conservatives here argue that the country's transition from communism has been incomplete as a result of powerful and corrupt cliques remaining in power and plundering the state. They have proposed rebuilding the country -- a "Fourth Polish Republic" -- on the basis of a new moral climate.

The EU is often compared by them to a Trojan horse for decadent, liberal values, to which a re-born Poland should not capitulate.

Concerned observers in Western Europe have pointed to troubling similarities between the twin brothers' ideology and Poland's pre-communist nationalistic, illiberal and anti-Semitic regime.

Poland is one of three EU states which prohibit abortion on demand. Alicja Tysiac was unable to find a doctor for an abortion in Poland in 2000, despite warnings that her pregnancy could result in damage to her eyesight. After giving birth, her sight did seriously deteriorate, she has claimed.

Tysiac filed a complaint against Poland in the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg in 2003. The court ruled in her favour last March, but the Polish government appealed against the decision. On Sep. 25, the court rejected Poland's appeal, confirming Tysiac's right to abortion and ordered the Polish government to pay her damages.

Much of the Western media has indirectly blamed Poland's Catholicism, which permeates much of the country's public life, not only for the country's abortion laws, but also for the government's flirting with the idea of capital punishment.

Poland abolished the death penalty, an essential requirement for joining the EU, in 1997. A moratorium had been in place since the time of the last execution in 1988. Poland joined the EU, currently a body with 27 member nations, in 2004.

Re: The Death Penalty and Abortion - the same?

Seeing as you brought up the subject, I might as well respond.

In the UK, abortion on demand has been on balance an absolute disaster.

Try to adopt a child now - nigh on impossible to get a relinquishment shortly after birth as it was in the 60s. You just get the abused ones now, and at an age where they are exceptionally difficult.

Young women (the ones left holding the baby) have requested mass slaughter to suit their social needs. Medical circumstances are only rarely an issue.

Young women in the UK have shown themselves to be increasingly unsuited to taking responsibility for their own fertility, as the disastrous abortion figures show every year.

But seeing as the Kaczynskis say mass abortion on demand is wrong, then it must be by definition what we all need every morning on our toast.

Once again, western Europe shows how illiberal it is!

Re: The Death Penalty and Abortion - the same?

Although I am more on the line of pro-choice rather than back street desperation, I can see the point they are trying to make and it is a valid one when you think about it. At the same time as foetuses are thrown in bins controversy rages over the ethics of using these for research..... what a complex world we live in these days.