Poland and Polish Discussion Group and Forum

Welcome to the original English language Poland and Polish discussion group board. This message forum is a place where English-speaking Poles, foreigners (expats) living in Poland, and anyone with a genuine interest in Poland can discuss and read the views of others concerning Poland. Subjects include: Polish news and current affairs; Life in Poland; politics; genealogy research; Polish culture and history; advice and tips on visiting Poland; Polish property and investment issues. The aim of our group is to increase awareness of wonderful Poland using the English language and allow and foster the honest debate and exchange of opinions on anything vaguely related to Poland and Polish - positive, negative and/or neutral! To state the obvious: all opinions and views expressed on this site are solely those of their respective authors and are not necessarily those of anyone else! Messages consisting of ads will be deleted.

Links:  Poland Directory; Polish Language Forum; Factbook Poland; Photographs of Poland; Polish TranslationA Town in Poland; Map

Poland and Polish Discussion Group and Forum
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
Poland from one German perspective

Poland Makes It Easy to Be German, TV Star Says

Recent high-level meetings between Berlin and Warsaw have prompted speculation about a new European alliance. DW-WORLD.DE spoke to one of the best-known Germans in Poland about relations between the countries.

Steffen Moeller first visited Poland 14 years ago on a two-week language course. He liked it so much that he decided to return for good. After seven years teaching German, he launched a career in cabaret and television. While still relatively unknown in his native Germany, the soap star and game show host has become a household name in Poland.

The German emigrant has also written a number of books, most recently "Viva Polonia" -- an account of his experiences living in Poland and a guide to his adopted homeland. In 1995, he was awarded the German Federal Order of Merit for his services to German-Polish relations.

DW-WORLD.DE: Were there many other Germans in your situation when you arrived in Poland in 1994? Has the situation changed at all since then?

Steffen Moeller: Quite a lot of Germans move to Poland with German firms. But they tend to remain within these firms as managers. I was one of the few who always had Polish employers. I do now occasionally get e-mails from Germans who have moved to Poland. But I don't think there are that many. I think that a lot more Germans go to Prague or Budapest.

Why do you think that is?

Poland and Romania have the worst reputation in Germany of all the European Union countries. Poland's is perhaps even worse than Romania's. I think it's linked to the fact that Poland is Germany's second biggest neighbor. The relationship to France, our largest neighbor has, as is well known, not always been good. That changed after the Second World War, because West Germany was part of the western bloc.

Relations with Poland have only been normal for the past few years. There is an awful lot of catching up to do. And, of course, there is a much bigger difference in the standard of living on the eastern German border. Many Germans have only come across Poles working in Polish markets and bazaars… and a lot of Polish car thieves. But that is becoming less and less of a problem, because the gap is closing.

The divide between the Germanic peoples and the Slavs that bisects Germany and Poland is probably a lot bigger than that between the Germanic peoples and the Romanic peoples. The reasons for that go back a very long way. The Germans were always fixated on the West. My brother lives in Paris. He tells me that the French have the same relationship to Germany as Germans have to Poland. For the French, Siberia begins at the Rhine and for us, it begins at the Oder River.

Have relations between Germans and Poles changed since you have been living in Poland?

Yes. More and more Germans and Poles are getting married. It's not about some German farmers picking Polish women from a catalogue. In 2005 alone, there were 6,000 German-Polish marriages. And more than 400 German and Polish towns are twinned with one another. There are a lot of school partnerships, too. But I'm not really sure that this is a growing trend. I think that in 2002/2003 there was a lot of interest on the German side after Poland's accession to the EU. I think that this might have waned a little.

Your book "Viva Polonia" appeared in German this year. Late last year, German publishing house Suhrkamp also published an encyclopedic guide to Polish culture. There does appear to be a market for books about Germany's eastern neighbor.

The Germans don't know a lot about Poland, and what I think is very sad is that you can't really study Polish in Germany. In all of Germany there is only one chair in Polish studies. There are people working in West Slavic Studies, but no experts purely for Poland. Berlin is only 80 kilometers (50 miles) from the Polish border, but it feels like a thousand.

Do the Poles know a lot about Germany?

The Poles are much more interested in other countries than other post-socialist states. Just think of the amount of emigration to England. Many Germans don't even realize that almost 2 million Poles are currently living in England.

You have become best known in Poland through your role as Stefan Mueller, a German farmer living in Poland, in one of the country's most popular soaps, "M jak Milosc" (L for Love). Why did this German figure become so popular in Poland? And the real Steffen Moeller?

I haven't actually appeared in the soap for the last six months. I am "resting." The nice thing in Poland is that soap opera characters don't have to die in plane crashes, they just get sent abroad. It's quite a legitimate means, since Poles are continually going abroad. I think that the character is popular because he's so hapless. He's unlucky in love, but he's really a nice lad whom everyone wants to help.

I also appear in an entertainment show about Europe. There I play the comedian and I display a characteristic that Poles don't expect from Germans: self-irony. It's easy to be a German abroad. You just have to play up the cliches a little and then subvert them, and presto, you're a cabaret star. There's no other country in Europe that has such a bad image as Germany, and that's a good starting point for cabaret.

So you actually profit from these stereotypes about the Germans?

Of course!

When Jaroslaw Kaczynski was prime minister, relations between Berlin and Warsaw were very strained. Last year, a new government took over. Do you think this marks a new chapter in German-Polish relations?

Definitely. The new prime minister, Donald Tusk, is trying to normalize German-Polish relations. He's also been successful. You can see that by the fact that Poland has hardly been visible in the German media for the past few months. It shows that everything is normal. Maybe my book sales have profited from it, since some Germans think it means they can now go on holiday in Poland. Of course, that's nonsense. Germans who visit Poland always expect to be confronted with the German past. On one level that is true -- but indirectly, in the sense of memorials and cemeteries.

It's interesting, but Poles treat us Germans very well. One reason is that the Russians marched in after the Germans and the memory of that is much stronger. But there's another reason. Mutual mistrust is the Polish national illness. Poles can't stand each other. If you travel to Cracow and you want to rent an apartment and there are six Poles who want to rent the apartment too, you can be sure that, as a German, you'll get the apartment. Not because the landlord loves you, but because he doesn't trust his fellow countrymen to pay the rent and the telephone. As Germans, we also profit from this economically, because we're regarded as trustworthy and honest, as well as naive and humorless.

What would you miss, if you moved away from Poland?

Their warmth. At Christmas I got 40 text messages from people I know -- some of whom I hadn't seen for three years. Really long ones. I got a single text message from a German acquaintance from my home town, Wuppertal. It simply said: "Happy Christmas."

They also have an absurd sense of humor -- also shared amongst strangers. When I'm asked by the Poles whether Germans have a sense of humor, I tell them: "Yes, but only in the evening when they're sitting in the cabaret and they know that they are allowed to laugh."

I have a plumber whose visiting card says "slow, expensive and unreliable." I asked him whether that was meant to be an advertisement. He told me that in Poland everyone realized it was a joke and rang up for that very reason.

What could be done to further improve the state of Polish-German relations?

I think a television station should be set up. Not for reasons of political correctness. It would be interesting to have reports from our European neighbors. That would do a lot to cement European identity. We could also build on what is there -- expand the existing partnerships.

http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,2144,3274653,00.html

Re: Poland from one German perspective

The man is an ass. But the article is fairly accurate.

Re: Poland from one German perspective

So you agree Polish/German relations are improving Hans?

Re: Poland from one German perspective

Well better than they were a few months ago. As I've said before the German view of Poles is distorted by the class of Poles who come to Germany. Largely people who can't make much money in Poland because of lack education or brains. And of course a proportion looking for a quick buck by stealing, etc.

Re: Poland from one German perspective

Comparatively few Germans see Poland first-hand as for many the country holds no interest. Especially since the cost of most things in Poland are now more expensive than in Germany. Notable exceptions being dentistry, haircuts, eating out, and alcohol.