The Lt. Columbo Forum

An area where fans from all over can ask each other questions and voice their own ideas and opinions on anything Columbo.

This Forum is fondly dedicated in memory of  "cassavetes45"  (Carleen Zink),
Columbo's greatest fan and a great friend to us all.
​​​​​​​
The Lt. Columbo Forum
Start a New Topic 
Author
Comment
A Trace of Murder Discrepancy

Let me see if I can explain this slowly so everybody understands.

When Columbo and Patrick are interviewing mrs. Calvert at Barney's Beanery, Columbo determines that the two know each other because of the sugar incident at the table. His suspicions are further verified when the car comes up and Mrs. Calvert gets into the front seat. He is shocked at that.

However, then we see Columbo getting into the back seat of the car. Followed by Patrick. Then all of them drive to the police station where Mrs. Calvert gets in her own car and leaves.

After a brief talk with Patrick, Columbo turns to the officer driving the car and questions him about where Mrs. Calvert sat on the way to Barney's Beanery. Herein lies the discrepancy. If Columbo rides back with them to the police station, then he obviously had to ride to the restaurant with them no? So he would have known that Mrs. Calvert took the front seat. Unless he got dropped off or came by cab. Because we know for a fact that he goes back to the police station with them. So he obviously didn't have his own car there. (Maybe that lovely gem was at Mikes Garage for service).

I know that that's wordy but I think I explained it properly if anybody has any input I would love to hear it

Re: A Trace of Murder Discrepancy

Great question.

As I recall, Patrick and Columbo were already at Barney's and THEN Mrs. Calvert walked in, having been given a ride by the officer who spends most of his time looking for the key witness - THE CAT. If she came with the officer, then how did Columbo and Patrick get there? And why did they go back to police headquarters in the same car? Were they get dropped off by someone else? Did they take a cab, like Alvin Deschler or Verity Chandler? Columbo would have a field day with the these "loose ends" which don't make sense.

P.S. - funniest thing happened when I had to VERIFY this post - the pictures came up and I had to identify the TAXIS!!!

Re: A Trace of Murder Discrepancy

No, he did not ride with them on the way to the restaurant. At Barney’s he asks Mrs. Calvert if the officer who drove her over had any trouble finding the place. Also, if Columbo rode to the restaurant with them, he would’ve known where she sat, and wouldn’t have needed to ask the officer in the garage where she sat. How Columbo and or Patrick got to the restaurant is not known. It seems that maybe Columbo got into the car because he was feeling sick. Patrick’s transportation on the way over is also not disclosed, and the complete scene (from the beginning of the restaurant to the end of the parking garage) also indicates that he did not ride Mrs. Calvert on the way over.

Re: A Trace of Murder Discrepancy

Columbo and Pat were already at the restaurant. I'm sure that Columbo had already inhaled a whole bowl of chili.

Columbo gets very lucky in this one because if the wedding photographer did not take a picture of Clifford and Kathleen dancing the whole case goes up in smoke.


Re: A Trace of Murder Discrepancy

As Columbo says in "Columbo Goes to College", "And luck. You have to be lucky."

He's always lucky.

Re: A Trace of Murder Discrepancy

John
As Columbo says in "Columbo Goes to College", "And luck. You have to be lucky."

He's always lucky.
Exactly.