Return to Website

Away From The Numbers

All good things come to an end. Or so they say. AFTN has been around since 1989, first as a fanzine and then making the jump to a website and forum in 2003. We've been through the many ups and down at East Fife in those 12 years but policing the forum has become a giant pain in the ass in recent years. As such, we made the decision not to renew it when it expired.

The forum is no more and will remain as a locked archive until it is eventually deleted by the host. We're looking in to try to save some of the content as an archive.

This is not the end of AFTN though. The site will continue and will be revamped and return in its full glory for the start of the 2016/17 season. Maybe even sooner. There will be a comment sections and possibly even a new, registered forum. Check our Twitter (@aftnwebsite) for all the latest info and we'll also post in on the EFFC memories Facebook page.

Until then, have a last browse here, thanks for all your support over the years, and 'Mon the Fife.

GoF

 

East Fife
This Forum is Locked
Author
Comment
Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

From the Scotsman today.

What can you say? I've a feeling you'll be in for a rough ride the next time you turn at Bayview Henry.

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

My polite response to that is: Oh for goodness sake![:

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

Every time that man opens his mouth he puts his foot in it

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

Just the sort of opinions we need to hear. Integrity is for selfish people after all.

He would know.
Financial mismanagement is his forté.
So it seems, is talking shite!

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

Published on Thursday 12 July 2012 05:30



HENRY McLEISH has urged Scottish Football League chairmen not to extend the uncertainty over which division Rangers will be playing in next season beyond tomorrow’s meeting at Hampden.



Former First Minister McLeish has backed SFA chief executive Stewart Regan’s stance that the Ibrox club should be accepted into the First Division in order to avoid what he says would be severe financial consequences for the whole of Scottish football.

According to McLeish, who compiled a wide-ranging review of the game in this country for the SFA, Scottish clubs do not have the “luxury of an ideal world” in which natural justice would see newco Rangers start life in the Third Division after their rejection last week by 
Scottish Premier League clubs.

Many SFL chairmen and directors have been angered by the pressure being placed on them to accommodate Rangers and the form of the resolutions they will be asked to vote upon tomorrow which could effectively allow the SFL board to agree to the First Division option against the wider wishes of their member clubs and supporters.

But amid suggestions the vote could now be postponed because of the level of discontent, McLeish has insisted a decision must be made tomorrow in the interests of all 42 senior clubs in Scotland.



“We can’t afford not to be able to move on after Friday,” said McLeish. “Unless or until we put our house in order, a lot of people will be looking at us and saying we are not fit for 
purpose. The game is bigger than the SPL, SFL and SFA. There is so much good work going on in the game.

“God forbid that anyone, after Friday, should think we can’t go forward. It needs confidence and it needs people to have trust and respect in each other. The game currently lacks that in a way which, even in 30 years in a rough trade like politics, I’ve never seen before.

“The clubs are taking a big 
decision for Rangers on Friday but an even bigger decision for Scottish football. They have to see the wider implications. If you looked at the SPL option [for Rangers], that would have ticked the box about keeping finances to the fore but would have done nothing as a fit and proper 
punishment.

“If you look at Rangers playing in SFL3, that ticks the box in terms of a fit and proper punishment but it raises concerns about finance and the future for Scottish football. If you look at Rangers playing in SFL1, then to me it can tick both boxes. It brings to a conclusion, I would like to think, the range of punishments that have been meted out. But it also satisfies the fact that a huge punishment has been delivered to the club 
in terms of their integrity and credibility.

“It is a balance and the fans may want to extract the maximum punishment, which is the Third Division. If you lived in an ideal world, a purist’s world, that would be fine. But we don’t have the luxury of that. In the position we are in, we can’t 
afford to take those lofty and philosophical decisions.

“I congratulate supporters for putting integrity and good governance of the game to the top of the agenda. The fans have done a good job, but it’s now time for them to join us in 
addressing the other issues in Scottish football.”

McLeish admits there is no hard proof of the apocalyptic figures which have been produced in recent days to illustrate the losses which would be suffered if Rangers are placed in the Third Division, but he is convinced it would cause significant problems for many clubs.

“I don’t have any empirical evidence to justify it but, in terms of the research I did, there are a lot of clubs in a very precarious situation,” he said. “How that would fall if Rangers went into the Third Division, you can’t identify the detailed consequences.

“But there is an instinct which many people share that it wouldn’t be positive for those clubs who are struggling on the margins. We are not like the Premier League in England where they are sitting on a fantastic amount of money. The game in Scotland is currently starved of investment. Much of that has to do with ourselves. We have to put our own house in order. No-one owes us a living.

“That means we have to close down some of these issues and move forward. There will be huge consequences wherever Rangers are but we have to make a decision, take those consequences on board and move on. No-one should be in any doubt that the game is not in a strong position to accommodate any consequences of a financial nature which are as dire as some people are predicting.”

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

Next time McLeish needs a bit of publicity making a token appearance at Bayview during a big game he should be told that he isn't welcome.

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

Here's a question that no one seems to ask

Has all this money from sky/espn or whoever actually made the game in Scotland any better?

Is the spl an exciting league to watch filled with top names?

Does the national team regularly qualify for tournaments?

Is there youth policies in place at all the big clubs producing home grown talent?

Or has the tv money allowed some clubs, who were probably quite prudent before, to go out and pay stupid wages to at best average overseas players and at worst total diddys and when was the last time a team outwith the OF won the league?

Would this 'armageddon' we are facing be a bad thing if in a few years we had a national team that qualified for something and the top league was filled with homegrown talent with more waiting in the wings?

Just a thought

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

LEFM
Here's a question that no one seems to ask

Has all this money from sky/espn or whoever actually made the game in Scotland any better?

Is the spl an exciting league to watch filled with top names?

Does the national team regularly qualify for tournaments?

Is there youth policies in place at all the big clubs producing home grown talent?

Or has the tv money allowed some clubs, who were probably quite prudent before, to go out and pay stupid wages to at best average overseas players and at worst total diddys and when was the last time a team outwith the OF won the league?

Would this 'armageddon' we are facing be a bad thing if in a few years we had a national team that qualified for something and the top league was filled with homegrown talent with more waiting in the wings?

Just a thought

Absolutely, 100% spot on!

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

LEFM
Here's a question that no one seems to ask

Has all this money from sky/espn or whoever actually made the game in Scotland any better?

Is the spl an exciting league to watch filled with top names?

Does the national team regularly qualify for tournaments?

Is there youth policies in place at all the big clubs producing home grown talent?

Or has the tv money allowed some clubs, who were probably quite prudent before, to go out and pay stupid wages to at best average overseas players and at worst total diddys and when was the last time a team outwith the OF won the league?

Would this 'armageddon' we are facing be a bad thing if in a few years we had a national team that qualified for something and the top league was filled with homegrown talent with more waiting in the wings?

Just a thought


They are the questions that the football establishment, their pals in rags like the Daily Rangers and Henry McLeish daren't ask. Good post.

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

LEFM
Here's a question that no one seems to ask

Has all this money from sky/espn or whoever actually made the game in Scotland any better?

Is the spl an exciting league to watch filled with top names?

Does the national team regularly qualify for tournaments?

Is there youth policies in place at all the big clubs producing home grown talent?

Or has the tv money allowed some clubs, who were probably quite prudent before, to go out and pay stupid wages to at best average overseas players and at worst total diddys and when was the last time a team outwith the OF won the league?

Would this 'armageddon' we are facing be a bad thing if in a few years we had a national team that qualified for something and the top league was filled with homegrown talent with more waiting in the wings?

Just a thought


You've hit the nail on the head there. The main benefactors of the TV money are the players. It's even worse in England, when Sky started paying gazillions for the rights to screen the games the wages rocketed, the ticket prices also rocketed way out of proportion with earnings.

It's about time things changed in Scottish football and hopefully this could be the catalyst. The fans of all clubs including Rangers fans and their manager think it best for a fresh start in Division 3, without that happening nothing will change for the better and the resentment over a newco parachuted into Division 1 will last for a long long time.

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

Absolute clown of a man. Last year Scottish football couldn't financially stand a bigger SPL, but now it's the only way forward?
Also, if McLeish, Doncaster and Regan can quantify the impending financial disaster of Sevco being in Div 3, how come they couldn't predict, and therefore avert, the whole business of Rangers going tits up in the first place?

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

His best line was that the Sevco shambles has "greatly divided opinion among clubs and fans". I can't think of any issue that has united fans of rival clubs more than this one.

Re: Henry McLeish urges SFL to put Rangers in First Division without delay

Dysart Lino
His best line was that the Sevco shambles has "greatly divided opinion among clubs and fans". I can't think of any issue that has united fans of rival clubs more than this one.


That takes the biscuit!